mailto:email@example.comMore bicycle articles by David S. Lawyer
Three-speed gearing for bicycles isn't too hard to understand but it's a lot more complex than the derailleur (aka derailer) bicycles which greatly outnumber 3-speeds today. Almost anyone can easily see how the derailleur works by just looking at the chain and the toothed wheels (aka sprockets = chainrings) at the front and back of the chain. But the internal workings of the 3-speed are hidden from view.
Although the 3-speed was invented shortly after 1900, it didn't become popular in the United States until the 1950's. And then by about 1970 it was surpassed by the derailleur. New 3-speeds became nearly extinct by the 1980's, but later on it was reintroduced on some so called "Cruiser" and "Comfort" Bicycles. But 3-speeds today likely account for only a few percent of the bicycle market in the United States.
There are also internal gear hubs with more than just 3 speeds, such as 5-speeds, 7-speeds, etc. They use some of the same principle as the 3-speed but are more complex, such as having sun gears that rotate. The simplest such hub is the 5-speed hub which is really nothing more than 2@ 3-speed systems combined inside the same hub. Thus learning how a 3-speed works can help understanding the hubs with more speeds. It might seem that combining 2@ 3-speeds in a hub would result in 6-speeds. But for every 3-speed sub-system, one of the speeds is just direct drive. So adding on an additional 3-speed mechanism only provides 2 more additional speeds in this case. But if the sun gears are allowed to rotate even more speeds can be provided.
This article is for readers who understand simple algebra and are mechanically inclined. You should be familiar with common hand tools like a ratchet, socket, screwdriver, and saw. You should be able to identify the basic components of a bicycle, like the chain, hubs, pedals, axle, etc. You should have seen a toothed gear wheel engaging with and turning with another such gear wheel, and understand gear ratios, etc. since the "gears" shifting of a derailleur bicycle are a lot simpler than a 3-speed it would help if you first understood how a derailleur works. But it's assumed that you know nothing about what's inside a 3-speed hub (except for ball bearings and an axle). Hopefully, you have also looked over a 3-speed bicycle and perhaps actually ridden one and shifted its gears.
So what is a 3-speed? If you look at a 3-speed bicycle, you'll see only one sprocket on each end of the chain. Derailleur bicycles have multiple sprockets (known as a cluster) on each end of the chain and the rider can use derailleurs to move the chain from one sprocket to an adjacent sprocket in order to change gears.
A sprocket is a circular metal disk with teeth on the circumference of the circle, and these teeth engage the chain. Sprockets often have large holes in their sides to reduce weight. The front sprocket(s) (often called a chainring) is pumped by the pedals via crank arms which rotate around a bearing housing known as the bottom bracket. On a 3-speed, the front sprocket (chainring) is larger than the rear one so that if the chainring is twice the diameter of the wheel sprocket, then for each turn of the crank (and chainring) by your feet, the rear sprocket spins 2 turns, resulting in the rear wheel turning twice as fast as it otherwise would if the sprockets were of the same diameter.
The 3-speed has only one gear ratio, yet the result is 3 gear ratios. Let's explain. Imagine one gear ratio, say 1 to 2. This could be obtained with just two gear wheels that engage each other, with one gear having twice as many teeth (and twice the diameter) of the other. This means that when one gear turns one revolution, the other gear turns two revolutions. Now if you want to increase the rotating speed of your rear tire-wheel (rpm or revolutions per minute), you put the input from the pedals-crank into the large gear and take the output to the rear wheel from the small gear. But if we connect up this gear set so that the input and output are interchanged, then the rpm of the output is cut in half rather than doubled. Thus with a 1 to 2 gear ratio, interchanging the input and output gives us a 2 to 1 ratio. In general, if a gear ratio is x, we can make this interchange, resulting in a ratio of 1/x. This is in fact what a 3-speed does. It gets two gear ratios from one set of fixed gears where one ratio is just the inverse (1/x) of the other. Where's the 3rd gear ratio in this? Well, its just direct drive (a 1 to 1 ratio) which doesn't require any gears at all.
Judging from the above, a 3 speed is simple, except for two things. First, it's nice to have the rotation of the input and output on concentric shafts: the input rear sprocket and the output rear bike tired-wheel rotate around the same center. Thus, a transmission with just two gears-wheels will not work since the input and output shafts are not on the same axis. To get the input and output on the same axis a 3-speed uses what are known as "planetary gears", also known as "epicyclic gears". Such gears were used for the model T Fords in the 1910's and for automatic automotive transmissions in the 1960's. Secondly, it requires various clutches (or the like) to interchange the input with the output.
Before explaining the mechanical complications of interchanging the input and output with clutches let's first discuss planetary gears that just create one gear ratio but do so with a concentric geometry.
Planetary gears (aka epicyclic gears) for a bicycle work like this. A planetary gear-system consists of 3 types of ordinary circular gears: sun, planets, and ring. To assembly one on a table top place an ordinary gear, called the sun gear flat on the table. Fix it to the table with glue, etc. It's actually rigidly attached to the rear axle (it can't turn) and is concentric with this axle. Then around the sun you uniformly place 3 or 4 planet gears, about the same size as the sun. Planets are also called "pinions" or "pinion gears" or "planet pinions". The planet pinions mesh with the sun. The planets are all at the same distance from the sun and all the same size. Then around this whole "solar system" you place a ring gear, which is a metal ring with internal teeth that engages the teeth of every planet. The ring gear is several times the diameter of a ring you might wear on your finger. We now have 6 gears in all: 1 sun gear, 4 planet gears, 1 ring gear. But there is still one major element missing: the planet carrier which we'll describe shortly.
Rotating the ring gear around the fixed sun gear causes all the planets to rotate, both around their own axes and around the sun too. Kind of a double rotation like the earth rotating both around its own axis and also rotating all the way around the sun once a year. But how do we capture the rotation of the planetary gears around the sun gear? After all, the individual axis of any planet gear is obviously not concentric with the sun.
To obtain another object rotating concentric with the sun and containing the planets, we create a "carrier" for the 4 planets out of a metal flat washer of about 4 cm. outside diameter and say 1/2 cm. thick to make it strong. Place the center of this washer over the sun gear so that it symmetrical covers the 4 planets (which are uniformly spaced around the sun gear). Then drill a small hole in the center of each planet and continue drilling through the flat washer. Then stick a pin (like a short, thick nail) thru each hole thereby connecting up the flat washer to each of the planets. Each planet is still free to rotate around its center pin (tiny nail-like axle). But the large-scale rotation of the 4 planets around the sun-gear is captured by the flat washer (aka carrier) which is concentric with the fixed sun gear and rotates at the same speed that the planets rotate around the sun.
Now, when the ring gear is rotated, the planet pinions circle the sun just as before, but now this flat washer rotates too. Of course, the planets, in addition to rotating about the sun, also spin around their own axes (the 4 pins). Since this flat washer has a hole in its center, the bicycle axle goes right through this hole and the washer is free to turn with respect to the stationary (non-rotating) axle.
To make the construction stronger, we'll place another flat washer (identical to the first one) at the other end of the pinion pins so that now the planetary pinions pins are supported from both sides. Note that this design must provide retention for the pinion (planet) pins so that they don't accidentally fall out of their holes. One can replace a worn out planet gear by just removing its pin. Then we'll weld some rods (or the like) to more rigidly connect the two flat washers to each other in their separated position with the pinions positioned on pins between the two washers. All of this is called the planet carrier (or planet cage): it carries the planets. It's not actually made from flat washers but is cast as one piece. It has holes for the pins and space for the pinion gears which rotate on these pins as well as space for the sun gear in the center.. One catalog lists a "planet carrier, complete" as including the pins and pinions.
This planet carrier (aka "planet wheel carrier") must do more than just carry the planets (or pinions). It must engage with clutches so that it can lock itself either to the bicycle rear wheel hub (to drive the rear spoked wheel) or to the sprocket (so the chain and your feet can drive it). Similarly, the ring gear also needs two clutches. There are various types of clutches and the various makes and models of 3-speed hubs differ mainly in the types and layout of the clutches. The clutches are cleverly designed. If you take apart a hub you may have a hard time identifying them. But before going into the details of the clutches, let's determine the gear ratio of planetary gears.
If we place the planetary gear system flat on a table top (and unglue the sun gear, so that it too can rotate around a thick vertical nail pounded into the table top thru a center hole in the sun gear), we can turn both the sun gear and the planet carrier and observe how far the ring gear has turned. Let's say we first note the initial positions (with respect to rotation) of the 3 concentric "wheels": the sun gear, the planet carrier, and the ring gear. Then, holding the planet carrier fixed, we rotate the sun x turns (fractional turns are allowed) from its initial position and then, holding the sun at x, rotate the planet carrier y turns from it's initial position. We then observe z, the turns the ring gear has rotated from its initial position. We claim that for given values of x and y, the result z will always be the same regardless of the sequence of inputing x and y rotations. For example, if we first rotate the sun by x (holding the carrier fixed at y=0) and then rotate the carrier by y (holding the sun fixed at x) then the value of z (the rotation of the ring gear) is the same as if we did the rotations in the opposite sequence: first rotate the carrier by y and then the sun by x. And it's also the same if we simultaneously turned the sun by x and the carrier by y even if we turned them in jerks and not necessarily simultaneously. Expressed as a mathematical function we assert that z = f(x,y). Once you convince yourself of this, calculating the gear ratio when the sun is held fixed at x=0 (as it is in a 3-speed bicycle) is easy.
We are going to place all three concentric "wheels" in their 0 positions and then turn the carrier one turn clockwise (with the sun fixed) and determine how many turns the ring gear turned . Expressed mathematically, we want to find z1 = f(0,1) where z1 will be the turns the ring gear has made and is also the gear ratio of the planetary system. This result will be achieved in two steps: 1. Turn both the sun and carrier one turn. 2. Holding the carrier fixed, turn the sun gear one turn back to its original position 0. The result will be f(0,1) turns of the ring gear since the first step made x=1 and the second step changes x by -1 bringing the resulting number of turns of x back to zero (x=0). This experiment proceeds as follows:
Lock all the 6 gears together so that the pinion gears can't rotate around their axles. You could just glue all the gear teeth together where the teeth are making contacts. All the gears are now just like one solid mass. Now for step 1, we rotate this mass clockwise one turn around the nail thru the sun gear, thus turning all three concentric objects (the carrier, ring gear and sun gear) through one turn. Note that we really didn't need to lock the gears together if we turn the sun gear and the carrier simultaneously at exactly the same speed (in revolutions per minute --rpm) the ring gear will follow just as if all gears had been glued together.) In this step 1: x=y=z=1, and since z=f(x,y) by definition, f(1,1)=1. But the answer we are seeking is f(0,1).
For step 2 we will, holding the carrier fixed at y=1, decrement x (sun gear turns) by l and observe how much more the ring gear turns beyond its current position at z=1. To decrement x by 1 means to turn the sun one turn, back to its initial position. To do this, unlock (unglue) everything (so pinions can rotate on their axles, etc.) and holding the carrier fixed to the table (at one turn, y=1), rotate the sun one turn counter-clockwise back to where it was originally at x=0. Now, based on the reasoning of the last paragraph, the amount of total rotation of the of the ring gear, f(0,1), is exactly the same as if we had initially held the sun gear fixed and turned the carrier one turn. Note that moving the sun gear counter-clockwise actually moves the ring gear further in the clockwise direction. So we now need to determine how much further the ring gear turned, f(0,1) - f(1,1) = delta-z due to the one-turn rotation of the sun gear back to it's original position where we know f(1,1) to be 1. Once delta-z is found, just add f(1,1) to each side of the above equation to solve for f(0,1), the answer we need.
In this step 2, the sun gear circumference has moved through distance Cs where Cs is the circumference of the sun (recall it was turned one revolution in step 1 and now is turned back one revolution). The pinion gears just translates this circumferential motion to the ring gear, but reverses the direction. This is because the circumferential velocity of a rotating planet-pinion gear is the same at any position on its circumference and the positions of interest here are the pinion-sun contact point and the pinion-ring contact point. So the ring gear in step 2 has moved distance Cs along its periphery in a clockwise direction. Thus the ring gear has moved delta-z = Cs/Cr revolutions and we can substitute this into the equation of the previous paragraph and solve the problem. But an alternative to this solution is to reason as follows:
Since in step 1 the ring gear moved one revolution clockwise (or distance Cr where Cr is the circumference of the ring gear) the total ring gear circumference movement is now Cs + Cr. So the number of revolutions the ring gear has rotated is obtained by dividing how far a point on its circumference has moved by its circumference. It's ( Cs + Cr ) / Cr. = 1 + Cs/Cr = 1 + Rs/Rr where the Rs is the radius of the sun gear and Rr is the radius of the ring gear. The last equality is true since C = 2 pi R where C is the circumference of a circle and R is its radius. Thus the gear ratio for the planetary system is just 1 + Rs/Rr (one plus the radius ratio of the sun to the ring gear). In other words it just 1 + R where R is the radius ratio. Since Rs< Rr, R < 1, and the gear ratio is always less than 2. Also note that this gear ratio doesn't depend at all on the diameter of the planet pinion gears.
Take the planetary gear system and place it on a table top with the table resting on the earth. Suppose we fix the sun gear to the table so it can't move or rotate (as is the case when it's fixed on the bicycle axle) and then rotate (drive) the planet carrier clockwise. The planet pinions are thus forced to circle the sun since their pins are attached to the planet carrier, but due to their engagement with the sun, they also rotate around their own axles. The outer edges of the pinions are moving clockwise and push the ring gear clockwise too. It may seem complicated but it's somewhat simplified because everything (the planets, carrier, and ring gear) are all rotating clockwise.
Now ask yourself the question of just how fast the ring gear rotates as compared to the carrier. What's the gear ratio? One way to calculate this is to rotate the carrier 1 turn and then observe how much the ring gear has turned. If the ring gear were to turn 1.5 turns then the gear ratio would be 1:1.5 or 2 to 3 (2:3). How much the ring gear rotates with respect to the earth (the table) is the sum of the rotation of the carrier with respect to the earth plus the rotation the ring gear with respect to the carrier. So if we turn the carrier one turn then all we need to determine is the number of revolutions that the ring gear turns with respect to the carrier. By adding this number and 1, we obtain the number of revolutions that the ring gear has turned with respect to the table (and this number is also the gear ratio). Now imagine that there was an observer on the carrier to observe how far the ring gear turns with respect to the carrier. This is similar to a rider (observer) on a merry-go-round that is analogous to the carrier with 4 large rotating pinion gears mounted on the flat surface of the merry-go-round instead of plastic horses. The stationary center of the merry-go-round represents the sun gear and there is an imaginary ring gear slightly larger in diameter than the merry-go-round located just beyond the circumference of the merry-go-round.
For that large planetary gear set, that observer would see both the ring gear and the sun gear rotate with respect to the carrier (the floor of the merry-go-round)
The observer on the carrier sees the sun gear, which is actually fixed, rotate counter-clockwise thru the same angle (and at the same angular speed of rotation, such as rpm) as a stationary observer on the earth sees the carrier rotate clockwise. For example, as the carrier rotates one turn, an observer on the carrier sees the stationary sun gear rotate one turn in the opposite direction. It's similar to a rider on a merry-go-round who senses that the world outside goes around one turn when it's actually the merry-go-round that makes one turn. But the outside world (including the stationary equipment at the center of the merry-go-round) appears to the rider to rotate in a direction opposite to the merry-go-round's rotation.
To our observer on the carrier, the apparent counter-clockwise rotation of the sun gear, forces the pinions to rotate clockwise. We have the teeth of the sun, pinions, and ring all moving in arcs around various centers at various radii but these movements all have one thing in common: the linear circumferential speed of all the teeth of all the gears is the same (to the observer on the carrier). The speed is measured at the circumference of any gear wheels where the circumference passes through approximately the center of each tooth.
For example, with a marker pen draw a black straight radial line on the carrier body (merry-go-round floor), passing thru the center of one of the planetary gears and extending out to the ring gear. Since it's a radial line, an extension of this line would also hit the center of the sun gear. This straight line is rigidly attached to the planet carrier and rotates with the carrier. Then, when the the system is at a halt, take a red marker pen and put 4 red dots along this line, but put the dots on the gear teeth and not on the carrier: One dot on a ring gear tooth, a dot on the teeth on each side of the planet gear (2 dots on the planet gear), and a final dot on the sun gear tooth. Thus we have one line and 4 red dots on gear teeth along the black line. When the system starts moving a little and the gears start to rotate, all the red dots will move off the black line. In reality, the line may not exactly intersect the tip of a particular gear tooth and the dot may have to be put in between two teeth. But imagine that each dot can be put in it's correct location and that it rotates with the gear that it should be drawn on.
Now rotate the carrier and see what happens. The black line remains fixed to the carrier, but the red dots, which were on the line, move off the line. When the red dot on the sun gear is 1 cm. (in arc length) away from the black line (measured along the circumference of the sun gear with a flexible tape measure) where are the other dots? It's easy to see that all the other dots are also 1 cm. in arc length away from the line since each dot has moved by the same number of teeth (such as 2.43 teeth). So the observer on the carrier, sees the black line remaining stationary and the red dots all moving the same arc length away from the line (at the same circumferential velocity).
This shows the circumferential movement of the sun and ring gear to be equal. It's just like the sun gear directly drove the ring gear with the pinion gear merely serving as a means to change the direction of motion. Remember that all the above assumes that the observer is on the carrier.
So what is the gear ratio to this observer? Let Cr be the circumference of the ring gear and Cs be the circumference of the sun gear. In one revolution, the dot on the sun gear has moved Cs and since all red dots move the same arc length, the dot on the ring gear gear has also moved arc length Cs. If the dot on the ring gear had moved Cr it would have moved thru an entire revolution. But it's only moved Cs which amounts to Cs/Cr of a revolution. Note that Cs/Cr is the ratio of the diameters of the sun and ring gears which we'll call R. One could also determine this gear ratio by dividing the number of teeth on the sun gear by the number of teeth on the ring gear.
So for one turn of the carrier the ring turns 1 + R turns with respect to the earth since the carrier has turned one turn and the ring gear has turned R turns with respect to the carrier. This results in a gear ratio of 1 + R, the same as found by the other explanation. Since the diameter of the sun is always less than the ring, R is always less than one and thus the gear ratio always lies between 1 and 2. It's also the inverse of this if the input and output shafts are interchanged by means of clutches. Since the pinion gears can't be too tiny, the ring gear must always have a diameter significantly greater than the sun gear, resulting in actual ratios of say 4:3. In the next section, we'll discuss clutches used to invert the gear ratio by interchanging the input and output.
Clutches for a 3-speed hub for a bicycle are quite different than clutches for an automobile. With a manual transmission auto, one is familiar with the clutch that smoothly locks the crankshaft of the engine to the transmission. An automatic transmission also uses clutches, but they operate automatically. A major difference between automotive clutches and bicycle ones (for a 3-speed) is that auto clutches can slip a little when they are first engaged, thus avoiding harsh jerks. Bicycle clutches engage directly without any protective slippage and assume that the bicycle rider is not applying much (if any) force with his foot when shifting gears (and thus operating the clutches).
A 3-speed hub needs 4 clutches for interchanging the input and output to a planetary gear system. But if you look at a diagram or parts list you will only find one clutch. Where are the missing clutches? Well, what is called the clutch can engage with two different rotating objects (not at the same time of course) and thus serves like 2 clutches. The remaining two clutches are free-wheeling, one way clutches (to be explained next) and the only named components of them are pawls and dogs.
One type of clutch used for 3-speed hubs is a one-way clutch which allows free-wheeling and is constructed using pawls and dogs. Dogs? A single dog is something like a ring-gear tooth (all the teeth face inwards and point to the imaginary center of the ring). But each tooth is more like the shape of a saw tooth than a gear tooth. A "dog ring" is just like a ring gear where each gear tooth is a dog instead of a tooth. Well, you could also think of a dog as a gear tooth with a different shape. The dog ring doesn't engage with any gear but provides bumps (or notches or lugs) for a "pawl" to push on it. For a 3-speed, the dog rings are large, almost the same diameter of the hub, and are rigidly attached to the hub. Pawls pushing against dogs are the main elements of a ratchet, like the socket wrenches used by mechanics for screwing on and off nuts and bolts.
This type of ratchet or one-way-clutch also provides for freewheeling where a bicycle wheel can spin, even when the pedals aren't being turned. All modern bicycles (including derailleurs) have freewheeling. But during the "golden age" of the bicycle in the 1890's, bicycles were not freewheeling and one had to pump (rotate ones feet) even when coasting. Free-wheeling principles are essential to the operation of the 3-speed hub. These mechanisms not only allow the 3-speed to freewheel, but also serve as clutches.
A freewheel or ratchet is a clutch that has a rotary input and a rotary output and is free to slip in one direction of rotation. For a ratchet socket wrench, the handle is the input and the output is the socket (which fits over a nut or bolt). If you are tightening a nut and apply torque to the input in say the clockwise direction, then the output becomes temporarily locked to the input and turns at the same rotation speed in the same direction (clockwise). However, if you hold the input fixed, the output may still freely rotate in one direction. More generally, if you rotate the input at a given speed (rpm) then if someone turns the output at a higher rpm, the output shaft will freely turn at this faster output and the input and output are no longer locked together. Try this if you have mechanic's ratchet wrench handy. In a bicycle, there's no need to reverse the direction of rotation for transmitting power like there is for a mechanic's ratchet where nuts and bolts need to sometimes be tightened (clockwise) and loosened (counterclockwise).
If you don't understand the ratcheting mechanism, get a hand wood saw (or possibly just a saw blade) and a common screwdriver (for slotted screws). Hold the saw level with the teeth pointing upwards to the ceiling or sky. Look at the teeth. Each tooth has one side nearly vertical and the other side sloped, forming a triangle. Then set the saw, teeth upward, on a table (or the like). Take the screwdriver, place the one side of its blade in parallel contact with the side of a sloped tooth of the saw (the screwdriver is tilted). Using a finger pressed against the screwdriver blade to keep the screwdriver blade from slipping off the saw-blade try sliding the screwdriver along the saw-blade. Note that for one direction of such sliding the screwdriver blade slides easily along the saw-blade. But push in the opposite direction and it will not slide but will push on the whole saw. This is like the action of a ratchet. Here the saw teeth are the "dogs" and the screwdriver blade is the "pawl". If you push on the screwdriver, it drives the saw. But if you pull on the saw in the same direction with the screwdriver kept stationary, the saw will just "freewheel" in that direction and the screwdriver and saw are not locked together anymore.
This experiment is for linear motion, but the same sort of thing happens for rotary motion. For a bicycle, the dog teeth are a couple of centimeters wide and there may be many such teeth on the inner circumference of the hub. These "dogs" (or teeth) are arranged in a circle on the inside of the rear wheel's hub shell (and rigidly attached to the hub shell) so it's called a "dog ring". It's something like a ring gear but the teeth are much different. Inside the hub shell there are two dog rings, each about 1/2 inch or so wide with a diameter just a little smaller than the hub. These rings must either rigidly lock to the hub so that they turn with the hub or the dogs may just be built into the hub so that the "dog ring" is just part of the hub itself. So when you look inside a rear hub on a 3-speed, you'll see dogs as part of the inside surface of the hub shell. If pawls attached to the ring gear or planet carrier turn the dog ring, the hub and attached bike wheel and tires all must then turn too.
One of the two dog rings in the hub is for the pawls on the planet carrier and the other for the pawls on the gear ring. Some dog rings can be unscrewed and replaced using tools but some can't and are part of the hub shell. In some cases, the dog rings may have been made separately, but were pressed into the shell when it was made so they can't be removed.
What do pawls look like. They only bear a little resemblance to a screwdriver blade (used in the example above) since they must be attached to the periphery of a rotating object and engage with a dog by spring action. So if you had to mount a screwdriver blade on a rotary part, you would likely make the blade and shaft rectangular, put a hole in it to mount it using a pin, and let it pivot abound the pin. You would also provide a small spring that pushes the tip of the pawl gently against the dog ring so that it will rub against the dog ring. There might even be some mechanism to retract the pawls so that they disengage from the dog ring, but more on this later.
Pawls are attached to both the planet carrier and the ring gear. They sometimes are mounted on a metal ring (pawl carrier) that is effectively locked to the planet carrier or to the ring gear. The pawls drive the hub via dog rings which can be considered to be part of the hub. If the hub is rotating faster than both the carrier and ring gear, then both sets of pawls will click and the bicycle is freewheeling: the wheel is spinning freely, just like the front wheel except for the clicks.
Now suppose that the bicycle is not freewheeling and both the planet carrier and ring gear are being driven by your feet via a clutch (not yet described). The clutch only drives one of these objects but since they are permanently geared together, the other object turns also. In other words the planet carrier and the ring gear always turn in unison with a fixed gear ratio between them. The ring gear rotates 1 + R times faster than the planet carrier. So the pawls of the ring gear drives the hub via the dogs. What happens at the carrier pawls? The hub is turning at the speed of the ring gear which is faster than the planet carrier. So by the freewheeling principle, if the dog ring rotates faster than the pawl carrier, the pawls just click and you have freewheeling here (turns freely). Thus there is no engagement between the pawls on the planet carrier and the hub. These pawls just click as they slip over the dogs. Thus the output power just comes from the ring gear as originally assumed.
But suppose we want the take the output from the planet carrier via the pawls? This would rotate the hub (via the dog ring) at the speed of the carrier. Since the ring gear is turning faster than the carrier (and faster than the hub), the ring gear's pawls would engage the dogs and force the hub to turn at the speed of the ring gear as described above. This contradicts the original assumption that the hub was turning at the speed of the ring gear. Thus, the only way to have the carrier drive the hub is to somehow disable the pawls on the ring gear so that they can't turn the hub as the ring gear rotates. This may be done by retracting these pawls so that they engage nothing. It can also be done by sliding the pawl carrier to one side, so that the pawls are no longer contacting the dog ring. Instead, the pawls slide freely on a smooth interior hub surface with no dogs contacting them.
We have explained above how the one-way clutches (consisting of pawls and dogs) operate. So how does a freewheel work on a derailleur bicycle? It's a lot simpler than the above. The input comes directly from the sprocket cluster on the rear wheel and the output is just the rear wheel.
Above we've described the pawl-dog-ring type "clutch" (aka one-way clutch), and mentioned that these are used for output from the planetary gear system. But what about the two clutches needed for the input to the planetary gears from your leg muscles via the pedals, chain and sprocket? This input is either to the planet carrier or the ring gear.
The two clutches needed are combined so that a parts list will only show one clutch since it is actually only one clutch which can engage either of two different objects (the planet carrier of the ring gear). This makes it function like two clutches. A simple type of clutch is used where the clutch is analogous to turning a bolt with a mechanic's socket (part of a socket wrench set). When the socket is pushed onto the bolt head, the socket and bolt are joined together and turn together (the "clutch" is engaged). When one slides the socket off the bolt head, the socket and bolt are disconnected from each other (the "clutch" is disengaged). Of course, to engage them, the bolt head and socket must be first be aligned and concentric with each other. In a bicycle hub, everything must rotate about the stationary axle in the center of the hub. So all the components of the rotating clutch must have a hole in the center of them for the axle to go through. A socket may be welded to the rotating carrier and/or welded to the ring gear (and concentric with them). Or it may just rotate directly around the main axle and be driven by the sprocket. In all cases the bolt and socket rotate around the main axle. The fact that they rotate around the same axle, automatically makes them concentric with each other.
Note that an actual clutch in a 3-speed doesn't look much like a bolt and socket but the principle of operation is similar. It's not easy to describe what a typical clutch looks like since various models of hubs have very differently shaped clutches.
As an illustration using the bolt and socket analogy, suppose the rear sprocket is welded to a deep hex socket that rotates around the main hub axle as the rider pumps the bicycle. Inside this socket is a hollow hex-head bolt with a nut welded onto the other end of the bolt, resulting in a 2-headed bolt called a "clutch". Then weld another socket to say the center of the planet carrier. Then when the deep socket (called the driver) is driven by the pedals, the double headed bolt clutch is slid so that one head of it engages the socket welded to the carrier, the sprocket drives the carrier so that the carrier and sprocket turn in unison and are locked together by the 2 sockets and the clutch bolt with 2 heads. But if this 2-headed bolt is slid so that it engages nothing on one end, then the clutch is disengaged and the carrier is not driven.
The above describes just one clutch, but what about the second clutch? That's easy. Just weld another socket to the center of the ring gear. Make at least one socket hollow enough so that the clutch hex head can completely pass through it and drive the other socket. It will look like a very short length of pipe with a hexagon shaped interior or like a fragments of a deep socket that's been sawed in half. So now the double-headed bolt-clutch has two possibilities for engagement. It can be slide so that it engages only the ring gear socket or only the carrier socket. With 2 possible things to drive it's like having 2 clutches. It's just one clutch that can engage (lock) itself to either one of two possible sockets.
In an actual 3-speed, the sliding double headed bolt-clutch is simply called a clutch and will not look much like a bolt, since the bolt analogy was used to illustrate the principle of operation using an object that most people are familiar with. The sliding of the clutch is controlled by a pull rod which moves back and forth inside the hollow rear axle. This pull rod is moved by the gear shift cable which is moved by a shifter lever near the hand-grips. This is the shifter that allows you to change speed. Of course, a cable can only pull in one direction so a spring inside the hub will move the clutch back in the other direction. This spring keeps the shift cable taught.
Now, how can the sliding of a rod (aka pull rod) inside a stationary hollow axle cause the sliding of a rotating clutch inside the hub? Well, the hollow axle can have a lengthwise double-sided slot in it and this internal sliding rod (see above paragraph) can be attached to a slider aka collar = thrust ring) which is like a ring placed over the axle with the ring connected to the pull rod by a pin, perpendicular to the axle, that goes through the double-sided slot. The slider slides back and forth along the hub's axle and pushes (slides) the clutch back and forth with it so that the clutch can engage either with the planet carrier or with the ring gear.
How is the mechanical connection made between the pull rod and the slider? It's by a pin called a "key". This pin can be thought of as a rectangular (not square) nut that the pull rod (with a threaded end) screws into (inside the axle at the slot in the axle). This rectangular nut is several times wider than it is high and the edges are sometimes rounded so that it looks almost like a pin (or circular rod, a little larger in diameter than the pull rod) with a threaded hole through its center of mass (which makes the pin a "nut"). The threaded hole in the nut is aligned with the center of the hollow axle. When the pull rod is screwed into it, the result look like a tee made of 2 rods (the pull rod is the base of the tee). There are also a pair of holes in the slider ring for this pin-nut. To assemble it, one positions the sliding ring on the axle over the slot in the axle and then pushes the pin through one of the holes in the sliding ring so that the pin also goes through the slots in the axle and comes out of the other hole in the sliding ring (located directly across from the entry hole). Then the pull-rod (with male threads on one end) is screwed into the side of this rectangular pin to hold the pin in place.
Some notes: The slot in the hollow axle (of the hub) is long enough so that the pin-nut (aka key) can move freely within the slot so as to move the sliding ring (and the clutch) back and forth far enough to shift gears. The pin-nut (key) isn't exactly round nor are the holes for it (in the sliding ring). This keeps the key from rotating and assures that the nut-hole in it is aligned with the pull rod. The key is made as short as possible and doesn't stick out any beyond the slider ring. There is some sort of a "keeper" to prevent this key from slipping out of position when the pull rod is unscrewed. Sturmey-Archer shapes the clutch (that fits over the slider ring) to also serve as a "keeper" to keep the key in position.
Note that in operation, the clutch is rotating with respect to the axle but the slider, attached to the sliding rod inside the axle, doesn't rotate. The resulting friction is insignificant since the force to propel the bicycle is not transmitted through it. There is significant thrust force here only when gears are being shifted.
Real clutches of course don't actually use hex-head "bolts" and "sockets" and such words (including "head") are never found in diagrams, part lists, etc. Instead of a hex socket (6 points) one might use what looks more like a 12 point socket which fits over a 12 point "head". The more points these sockets have, the less load on each point since the points share the load. Two of the sockets are formed as part of the bodies of the planet carrier and ring gear and are not really welded on as described previously for simplicity. The "hollow bolt with 2 heads" might be called a "clutch gear" and the driver socket that one end of it fits into functions like "spline" but the word "spline" is nowhere to be found in the parts list since it's just part of the "driver". Thus the clutch may look like a couple of gears on a short hollow shaft which is cast as one piece and slides back and forth along the axle. Thus it's sometimes named "clutch gear". The gear "teeth" are flat on top and thus the "gear" is sometimes called a "spline". Such shaped "teeth" can't be used to drive another gear so the name "gear" is really a misnomer. But it looks almost like a gear.
The Torpedo hub by Sachs (now SRAM) called the "key" (pin-nut) a "sliding block" which also functioned as the sliding ring (although there was no ring part). It looked more like a rectangular nut and not like a pin and the edges of the slots in the axle guided its sliding. Its ends directly contacted (and rubbed against) the rotating clutch and moved it back and forth guided by an internal groove inside the hollow part of the clutch. The return spring acts directly on the sliding block so that the spring force is not transmitted through any rotating part (in contrast to Sturmey-Archer) thereby reducing friction.
The Sturmey Archer AW 3-speed hub didn't use a gear-clutch since the sprocket turned (drove) a hollow drive shaft (like a piece of pipe) which had 4 wide axial slots in it for the ends of a metal cross clutch (like a large plus sign) to project out. The cross, had a hole in its center for the main axle to pass thru. This cross-clutch could slide back and forth and the ends of 4 arms of the cross could engage either the planet carrier or the ring gear. To engage the planet carrier, the 4 arms of the cross engaged with the 4 projecting ends of the planet gear's round pins. It was a simple but crude design, since there were high forces in the clutch-pin contact. It thus tended to deform the ends of the pins, which fortunately reduced the original pressure of a flat object pushing against a round one. But it's claimed that misalignment of the clutch-pin contact would result in constant sliding of the contact point as it rotated. The resulting wear would eventually cause the clutch to suddenly slip out of high gear if the rider was standing up on the pedals (pumping hard). This is reported to have resulted in serious accidents where the rider falls over the handlebars when it suddenly slips out of high gear. See http://faqs.cs.uu.nl/na-dir/bicycles-faq/part4.html.
This cross-shaped clutch also could engage the ring gear by sliding it away from the carrier (where the cross drove the 4 pins of the planets). Two ends of the cross would engage with two dogs on the ring gear at a location away from the ring gear teeth. The ring gear was over twice as wide as the teeth with a ring of teeth on one side and a couple of dogs on the the other side (something like a dog ring previously described). Thus sliding the cross-clutch away from both the planet carrier and the ring gear would disengage the planet carrier but engage the ring gear to the cross via the dogs. One would normally expect to engage the clutch to the ring gear by moving the clutch towards the ring gear but this is just the opposite and it's why the dogs that the clutch engages are significantly offset from the teeth section of the ring gear.
To take the output from the planet carrier, we must disable the pawls on the ring gear as previously explained so that these pawls no longer drive the hub shell and wheels. This happens in low gear where the drive will be taken off the planet carrier pawls and the faster spinning ring gear will not be allowed to drive the hub via its pawls.
Sturmey archer TCW-3 and AW hubs just retracted the pawls. The cross-clutch directly contacted the pawls to push up in back of the pawl pivot point so that the pawl would pivot so as to retract (come down). A pawl is like a teeter-totter: You push one half of it up and the other half comes down since it can rotate a little around its pin. The pawl is shaped and positioned such that the half that is pushed up doesn't touch the dogs. Thus in low gear, the cross-clutch both drives the ring gear and retracts the pawls. To do these two things at the same time it uses 2 of its 4 arms to drive the ring gear and uses the other 2 arms to retract the pawls.
The early Shimano hubs used a method similar to Sturmey Archer but made the pawls do double-duty. When the round clutch with 4 short lugs on it, moves inside the cylindrical pawl carrier for the ring gear, it both pushes the lower sides of the pawls up just enough to disengage them and also pushes on the pawls so that the clutch can drive the ring gear via the pawls. Thus the the pawls, which function normally as a clutch to drive the dog ring (when in high gear), also function to convey torque from the sliding (driving) clutch when in low gear (input to drive the ring gear).
The Shimano clutch had a small part of it which was round like a pipe and had no lugs (dogs) on it. The leading edge was tapered so as to push up the bottom of the pawls (retracting the tops of the pawls) when the clutch slid along the axle. When this non-lug part of the clutch was under the pawls, it only lifted up the pawls but didn't drive the ring gear since the lugs on the clutch were still driving the carrier. Thus you obtained direct drive from the carrier pawls by retracting the ring gear pawls. In this position, about 1/3 of the clutch is driving the carrier, another 1/3 of it is retracting the ring gear pawls, and the remaining 1/3 is in empty space between the ring gear and the carrier.
Sachs (SRAM) slid the pawl carrier so that the pawls no longer contacted the dogs but just slid on a smooth surface. The pawl carrier was free to slide axially and still be connected to the ring gear via pins. The ring gear's pawls would just freely slide along the smooth interior surface of the shell hub while the clutch drove the planet carrier which drove the hub with the ring gear spinning faster but to no avail.
By first understanding planetary gearing and clutches it's easy to understand how the system works. Let's start with high gear. This means we must drive the carrier and take the output from the ring gear. All we need to do is to slide the clutch on the driveshaft to a position where it engages the carrier. This locks the carrier to the rear sprocket and chain. Then we need to take the output from the ring gear. This output is automatically put on the hub via the pawls and dog ring as previously explained since the ring gear rotates faster than the carrier. So all we need to do for this case is to just drive the carrier.
For the middle gear, we just want direct drive. So slide the clutch so that it slips out of driving the carrier and slips into driving the ring gear. Then the pawls on the ring gear drive the hub. The turning of the ring gear (due to the planetary gear system) also turns the carrier at a slower speed than the hub, but the pawls on the carrier just freewheel and don't drive anything.
For low gear we continue to drive the ring gear and make the pawls on the carrier drive the hub by disabling the pawls on the faster spinning ring gear. The clutch moves from the middle gear to low gear position but it still drives the ring gear. This new position activates a method for disabling the pawls on the ring gear. See disable-pawls
An alternative method for middle gear (direct drive) is to continue driving the carrier but to retract the pawls on the ring gear so that they no longer drive the hub. Then the hub is driven by the pawls on the carrier and since the clutch is driving the carrier it's direct drive. The old Shimano 3-speed used this method.
It should be obvious that the main differences between the various makes and models of 3-speed hubs in in the design of the clutches (although they only have one part named the "clutch"). There are also difference in how pawls are disabled but in the broad sense, pawls are just a part of the clutch system.
I once hoped that both coaster brakes and speeds greater than three could be covered in future revisions. But I'll never have time to do this so I'm asking for volunteers. Also, this article could have been better written by someone who has a lot of experience with 3-speed overhaul. I've only worked on a few of them, mostly decades ago. How do the various brands of 3-speeds compare? Sturmey-Archer needs to be given credit for inventing it (It was designed by Sturmey and Archer) and their basic design has been copied by others, sometimes with only minor improvements. Shimano (Japan) seems to have made significant improvements but doesn't seem to adequately supply parts for repair (in contrast to Sturmey Archer in the past) for their older hubs. SRAM (Germany) could be the best of them all. The author realizes that diagrams would better help explain this article but has neither the software, time, nor skills to create them.